Pop Mart’s Sales Halved. Collectables Aren’t Dead.

Pop Mart’s sales roughly halved last quarter. Call it the Labubu crash. I read the numbers twice, and I won’t pretend I read them calmly.

I sell collectables for a living, among other things. When the company that turned blind boxes into a global obsession loses half its revenue in three months, buyers notice. A few of them will be in my inbox this week asking whether the party’s over.

It isn’t. But somebody should explain what actually happened, because the headlines have it slightly wrong.

What actually happened

The big falls came outside China. Asia-Pacific was down 65 to 70% and Europe 50 to 55%. In mainland China, Pop Mart’s own shops slipped by only 5 to 10%, while online sales, where the flippers do their business, fell by almost half. You don’t need an analyst for that one.

Pop Mart tried to beat the scalpers by making roughly ten times more Labubu, and it worked a bit too well. Resale prices halved and some models now go for less than retail. The people who used to queue outside the shops at dawn stopped turning up. They were never collectors. They were traders, and a trader with no margin goes off to find something else to trade.

We’ve been here before

Anyone who was around in the late nineties remembers Beanie Babies. People bought them as an investment, the resale market fell off a cliff, and half the attics in Britain are probably still full of them. Nobody stopped buying soft toys. What died was the idea that a plush bear was a pension plan.

The fans are still buying

Meanwhile, Pop Mart’s revenue is still 70 to 90% higher than two years ago. Twinkle Twinkle grew almost sixfold in the first half, and six different characters each sold more than a billion yuan. The customers haven’t disappeared. The speculators have, and an awful lot of people who simply like the things are still buying. Plenty of brands would swap their best year for Pop Mart’s worst quarter.

Then go and walk a fair. I was in Shanghai a fortnight ago and collectables were everywhere, each with an influencer filming it. Deauville has more than a hundred kidult buyers registered for its Fanzone later this month, and Circana says blind packs and collectables are still growing double digits in Australia. Hardly a dying category.

What the Labubu crash really kills

What the Labubu crash does finish off is the one-character business. If your entire collectables plan was one cute face and a healthy resale market, you’ve got a problem. If you’ve got several characters, a proper release plan and real fans, you’ve got a correction. Corrections happen. Ask anyone who’s been in this industry more than five minutes.

I’ll have this conversation a dozen times before Nuremberg and I’ll give the same answer every time. Buy less hype and more depth. And if a range only sells because people think they can flip it for double next week, that’s a bet, not demand. Guess who’s holding the stock when it goes wrong.

Collectables aren’t dead. The traders have gone home, and frankly the shelf is better off without them.

Similar Posts